ANALYSIS: Authorities crack down on youth groups (10/24/04)

ANALYSIS

Authorities crack down on youth groups

by Taras Kuzio
Eurasia Daily Monitor

On October 15 Ukrainian Prime Minister and presidential candidate Viktor Yanukovych told foreign diplomats in Kyiv that the government is taking all measures to ensure a free and fair election on October 31 (Ukrainska Pravda, October 15). Officials will ensure observance of the rule of law, democratic principles and equal access to the media, he assured.

Now in its fourth month, the Ukrainian election campaign has been dominated by widespread abuses and violations, as the U.S. State Department warned on the same day as Mr. Yanukovych's speech to diplomats. Mr. Yanukovych's claims of being in favor of a free and fair election are not plausible, as the authorities have launched a nationwide effort to repress opposition forces. To ensure that Mr. Yanukovych is not confronted by opposition demonstrations during his campaign appearances, members of youth groups are arrested before he arrives (http://maidan.org.ua).

Members of the Pora (It's Time) youth movement, modeled on Serbia's Otpor and Georgia's Khmara, were arrested in western, southern and eastern Ukraine (see pora.org.ua and kuchmizm.com). During a search of Pora's Kyiv office, witnessed by opposition parliamentary deputies, the police found nothing incriminating except anti-Yanukovych leaflets. But during a second search, with only the police present, a bomb was allegedly found.

The Procurator General then launched a criminal case accusing Pora leaders of "terrorism" and "destabilization of the situation in the country." Pora was accused of being an illegal "military formation - a terrorist group" (Ukrainska Pravda, October 16). The Procurator General's Office has attempted to link the alleged bomb to the August terrorist act in a Kyiv market, which it had originally blamed on political parties allied with Our Ukraine.

A widespread media campaign has linked Pora to Our Ukraine, and thus to its presidential candidate Viktor Yushchenko, whom the authorities have been desperate to portray as an "extremist" (temnik.com.ua, October 18 and 19). Pora members issued a statement describing themselves as the "vanguard of peaceful opposition." They called upon all of their activists and Ukrainian citizens to "legally, peacefully and in a non-violent manner defend constitutional rights and freedoms in Ukraine" (pora.org.ua, October 18).

Over the same weekend, armed members of two pro-presidential parties, Yanukovych's Party of Regions and Viktor Medvedchuk's Social Democratic Party United, tried to break into the opposition newspaper, Vecherni Vesti, which is linked to Yulia Tymoshenko, a key Yushchenko ally. A spetsnaz (special assignment) unit of the Internal Ministry also attempted to break into the prestigious National University of Kyiv Mohyla Academy to locate Pora supporters, but officials refused to allow them in without a search warrant.

These pre-emptive actions against the opposition were part of a failed attempt to disrupt last weekend's student rally in Kyiv. Some 20,000 students from throughout Ukraine rallied in support of Mr. Yushchenko's candidacy (razom.org.ua/album/152/).

In a related action, Ukrainian Border Troops prevented Aleksandar Maric, a founding member of Otpor, from entering the country. The Security Service of Ukraine and Foreign Affairs Ministry have refused to provide an explanation, especially as Maric had a one-year multi-entry visa.

Otpor has been training Pora members under the auspices of the Citizen Participation in Elections in Ukraine (CPEU) program run by Freedom House, the National Democratic Institute and the International Republican Institute, and funded by the U.S. Agency for International Development. Otpor had also been cooperating with the Znayu (I Know) civic education and election youth group (znayu.org.ua).

Presidential spokesman Vasyl Baziv has argued that the action taken against Otpor is both legal and in the interest of Ukrainian national security (Interfax-Ukraine, October 15). But, as Freedom House pointed out, the CPEU program is legally registered with the Ministry of Justice and "operates in full compliance with Ukrainian laws" (freedomhouse.org). Such "learning across borders" is an "integral and accepted part of programs" used to encourage democratization throughout the world, according to a Freedom House press release.

This is certainly how the opposition understands U.S. assistance programs. But Ukrainian authorities are visibly paranoid about the threat of a Serbian or Georgian-style popular revolution occurring in Ukraine to protest election fraud. One week before the arrests and deportations, the pro-presidential camp had clamored for the National Security and Defense Council to take tough action against opposition plans to undertake mass civil disobedience (Ukrainska Pravda, October 7).

Valeriy Pustovoitenko, head of the group coordinating political parties that support Mr. Yanukovych, warned that regional organizations of his own People's Democratic Party throughout Ukraine were reporting that "certain forces are preparing for disturbances on election night in all of Ukraine's regions" (Ukrainska Pravda, October 13).

Our Ukraine National Deputy Taras Stetskiv retorted that opposition and civic groups are merely attempting to ensure as few violations as possible on election day, given the laxity of law enforcement bodies and election officials. The Yushchenko campaign also issued a statement claiming that the authorities were losing control of the situation and were not confident of Mr. Yanukovych's victory (razom.org.ua). This was admitted by presidential adviser Mikhail Pogrebynsky, who said, "We have a situation whereby the bigger part of the authorities' team does not believe in their success." He added that there was a widespread "feeling that the authorities will lose" (glavred.com, October 6).

Emphasizing their concerns, Oleksander Milenin, vice-minister of internal affairs and head of Kyiv's police, leaked to the Financial Times (October 19) the existence of a new "ninja" police unit "trained in special measures." He also claimed that "new means" had "been approved by the Health Ministry" and were available to suppress protests. These developments emboldened Mr. Milenin to say that "There won't be any revolution here" in Ukraine.

Taras Kuzio is visiting professor at the Elliot School of International Affairs, George Washington University. The article above, which originally appeared in The Jamestown Foundation's Eurasia Daily Monitor, is reprinted here with permission from the foundation (www.jamestown.org).

| Home Page |